This was a delightful Christian historical novel, featuring a fast-paced mystery and a little romance. The plot definitely kept you turning the pages! I additionally love that the characters were given very unique personalities – filled with character flaws we could all relate to. This novels main character, Carrington Brouwer, is a young woman seeking to be loved for who she is, flaws and all. Due to the death of both her parents she becomes dependent on the offered charity of one of her father's previous painting students and her wealthy family. After moving from Paris to Ohio she discovers her presence is largely unwanted by the female head of the household. She struggles to fit in, and to find worth after such a drastic change in her family life and her circumstances. Although she does develop an earthly love interest during the plot, the overarching need to trust and be loved by her heavenly father is what helps see the main character through many trials in this great book. I also loved the factoids about the creation of the beautiful carousel animals. The daily operations of a carousel factory were not something I knew a lot about before reading this book, but it was obvious that Judith Miller had done her homework (as usual) and the factory setting seemed to come alive with realism. A wonderful story.
This cover is quite beautiful. If I had spotted it in the book store it would have captured my attention. The red striping and a decorative scroll pattern mimics the carvings on carousel animals. They are used well throughout the cover and even help to capture attention on the spine. I like that although the carousel horse on the cover is quite beautiful, the focus is blurred so that the female behind it is the true focus of the photo. Hair style and dress on the female in the photo seem appropriate for the historical setting of the novel, but her dress is not overtly colorful or fancy and the focus is decidedly on her expression. She appears happy, mysterious … and a little proud of her work as she stares at the painted pony in the foreground.
I was a little unsure about the back cover carousel photo at first. Because the title is regarding a carousel painter it seemed odd to show a carousel in such fast motion that you couldn't really even see the animals, much less their paint job. However, when you read the teaser text beneath it you realize that it's a subtle statement about how what seems to be a perfect job for this novel's main character – turns out to have a lot of confusing ups and downs. (She is the first woman to work at the factory, and both the workmen and their female relatives are upset about it.) I'm glad that this photo of the carousel in motion was not the chosen style for the front cover, but feel it was a good choice for the back cover, in order to give readers a hint that the main character's life won't be calm and pretty throughout …